How did you decide?
You told them what you did. But did you show them how you decided? Why strong results aren't always enough, and how to tell whether your answers show the way you think.
Susan Callaghan, Founder
You received the email: "Another candidate was more closely aligned with the role."
What does that even mean? Nothing.
But I can tell you this: a common stumbling block for candidates is that they don't demonstrate how they make decisions. They don't prove they have excellent critical thinking skills and a solutions orientation.
Those are key things every decision maker looks for in the person they're going to hire. Can this person make good decisions with sound judgment?
With the AI transition the workforce is experiencing, I believe critical thinking has become a priority for decision makers. AI can produce an answer. It takes judgment to know whether it's the right one. So you have to prove you have it.
Why a good result isn't enough
A result tells an interviewer what happened. It doesn't tell them what will happen when you're facing their problem, with their constraints, and nobody has the answer yet.
That's what they're trying to predict. Every role comes with decisions nobody can script. The hiring manager needs to believe you'll make sound ones when the information is incomplete, people disagree, and the answer isn't obvious.
If your reasoning stays invisible, they have to guess. A good outcome with invisible reasoning looks like luck, and nobody hires for luck.
In the debrief, you would hear it: "There was just something missing. I couldn't follow how they did certain things." The result was there. The reasoning wasn't.
Everybody has access to the same polished answer, so interviewers have to look past it. That's why the follow-up questions come: Why did you do it that way? What else did you consider? What did you give up? What resistance did you run into?
You can memorize an answer. You can't memorize how you think.
Think about your last interview
Critical thinking isn't about sounding smart or having the perfect answer. It's whether someone can follow how you assess a situation, identify what matters, and arrive at a decision. Take one example you shared and ask yourself four things.
Did you show how you saw the problem?
Did you explain what was really going on, or jump straight to what you did? Did you show why the problem mattered to the business? Did you consider it from a broad range of perspectives, or only from your own seat?
Did you show what you weighed?
Would the interviewer know you didn't just act on your first idea? What sources of information did you consider? How did you test your thinking? What did you trade off, and why?
Did you show what you saw coming?
Strong critical thinkers recognize patterns and play things out several steps ahead. What consequences did you anticipate? What did you do about them before they became problems? Did your solution account for the people who had to support it and adopt it? A smart solution nobody adopts doesn't solve the problem.
Did you show how you moved forward?
Interviewers aren't only listening for what you know. They're listening for what you do when you don't. When something failed or the path wasn't clear, did you stay stuck in the problem, or show how you moved through it? What did you need to learn? How did you adapt? Did you bring the problem forward with a solution?
Could they follow you?
Showing how you think doesn't mean walking through every step. Too little detail and your reasoning stays hidden. Too much and the interviewer loses the thread, along with confidence that you know what matters.
You need enough detail to earn credibility, and not so much that you lose your audience. That level changes depending on who is across from you.
So try this test: could someone who knows nothing about the situation follow your answer? Would they understand the problem, the actions you took, and the result? Would they also understand why you made the decisions you made?
How much of your thinking are you showing?
Nobody is going to give you feedback that says, "I couldn't follow how you did it." You'll hear that another candidate was more closely aligned, and you'll be left wondering what they had that you didn't.
Sometimes the difference isn't the result. It's that they made their thinking easy to see, and that gave the hiring manager evidence they could stand behind.
So go back to your strongest example and take the result away. Is there still enough in your answer to convince someone you can solve their problem?
Want to see how this works?
Join my live, back-and-forth workshop, Prove you are interview ready: Demonstrating your critical thinking skills. It's 45 minutes, at no cost, and limited to 20 people per session.
Reading about it is a start. Practicing it is what changes the outcome.
Bring what you're working through to a discovery call and we'll build a plan around it.